A pile of handmade crocheted plush toys, including a mint green dinosaur, a purple dinosaur, a white duck, and several white fluffy ghost characters, arranged together on a patterned fabric background.

Handmade crochet stuffies

Come see what I've been up to! You'll find an array of handmade whimsy and fun to bring a smile to anyone.

Shop All Stuffies

Shop by Collection

What's new!

View all

Love it, but need it in a different color?

Let's work together to make your PERFECT stuffie! Many color options are available!

Request Custom Colors
Sarah Mae knitting and drinking coffee.

Meet the Maker

I create every stuffie by hand, turning colorful yarn into tiny characters full of personality. Learn more about me, the maker behind Sarah Mae Crochet.

About Sarah

  • handmade

    Every stuffie is crocheted by hand, one stitch at a time.

  • small to big

    I love making playful creatures of all sizes - perfect for gifting, collecting, and cuddling.

  • unique

    Subtle differences in stitching, shape, and details give every handmade stuffie its own personality.